Sins. Survival. Sacrifice.Life is chilly but normal in Martha's Vineyard during the off season. Two friends, glass-blower Kat and wildly rich Hunter, decide to continue celebrating the first day of off season by heading out on Hunter's boat for a late-night ride. Kyle, the new bartender on the island, accompanies them. Although inebriated, the three start their offshore party enjoying one another and the frigid air—until Hunter passes out drunk and Kyle's intentions for Kat turn sinister.When Kyle refuses to hear the word no, Kat defends herself and suddenly Kyle goes overboard, his terrified eyes the last thing Kat sees—the one thing she continues to see each night in bed. But was it Kat who shoved Kyle, or was it Hunter when he came to her rescue? To stay out of prison, Hunter insists they go back home. After all, Kyle probably swam back to shore. Right?Kat relents under the pressure but doesn't sleep a wink. Her boyfriend of six years and the son to her boss, Sean, knows nothing about what happened that night. As the news of Kyle's body washing ashore hits TV screens, Sean doesn't become suspicious. Rather, it's the intense feuds and strange reactions he sees between his girlfriend and Hunter that raises his eyebrows: was Kat cheating on him?As Sean contemplates this potential affair, there is one islander who becomes suspicious of Kyle's death: Ashley, a woman whose whole life revolves around the ocean, its tides, and its specks of sand. How could Kyle have washed up where he did? He died somewhere else, according to the tides and her research.Who really shoved Kyle overboard? Is there more going on between Kat and Hunter? And will Ashley ruin everyone's lives if she keeps snooping around?Meg Little Reilly throws a punch with this psychological thriller. Reminiscent of Mary Kubica's and Ruth Ware's novels, Everything That Follows delivers with powerful plot twists, dynamic characters, and the big question: what does self-preservation mean to each individual faced with murder?*I received a copy of this book from the publicist in exchange for an honest review*