The authors of Ribbons of Scarlet were have a book tour event near me, so I listened to it in a burst, as soon as it was released. It was riveting. My initial misgivings about an anthology-style book that swapped characters were invalidated. I'd been afraid I wouldn't connect as well with the characters, but I actually sobbed on-and-on during the heartrending ending of the book! I was emotionally invested, even while reaping the benefits of hearing about the revolution from all sides. Bravo to these authors!
I am thrilled at this concept of presenting all sides, as it’s the nature of things to empathize with your main characters—of becoming biased in favor of a protagonist’s side. Even though most of these protagonists tended towards the revolutionary side, we had the chance to be truly sympathetic to even the royals. Hurrah for fair treatment, and I hope this is a growing trend in historical fiction.
I did attend the author talk, and it was super! I loved what Sophie Perinot had to say about how history isn’t linear and how she can think of many ways women had it better in 1254 (her first book’s setting) than in later periods of history. I especially appreciated her telling us that the ‘modern sensibilities’ of the women of their book are indeed authentic. The novel did start off a bit unexpectedly with regards to the mores of the time. I’m sure the authors were excited to reveal some of the more ‘modern’ perspectives of that time period (1790’s, French Revolution), but I’d have preferred if they’d eased into it some. Any of the other characters would have suited this purpose more readily than Stephanie Dray’s Sophie de Grouchy…for all that she was fascinating and often admirable, and Dray seemed to capture her well.
Sophie Perinot took on the task of representing the royalist perspective—while at the talk assuring us that she is absolutely not a royalist! She wrote her section in 1st person present tense, in contrast to the rest of the book. While I love present tense, I was surprised by this inconsistency, and even more so that I didn’t notice this shift until after hearing the audiobook, only when flipping through the book. Perhaps it's on-purpose, a way of setting the princess aside from the revolutionaries, reminiscent of royals speaking in first-person plural. Obviously it didn’t bother me too much.
Kate Quinn was so charming and adorable! She left me starry-eyed. When I was at the bookstand, looking at her book The Huntress, she strolled by and tapped her finger on it. “That one’s rubbish,” she quipped. Totally made me laugh—and what an amazing thing to happen, the author popping by to tease while you’re perusing her book! She didn’t even let on she was the author. I haven’t read The Huntress yet, but her previous book, The Alice Network, is amazing, and her section of Ribbons had me going back to look at her writing style, specifically, to see just how she’d managed to grip me as she did! [I liked it so much that I immediately began listening to The Alice Network when I finished Ribbons.]
Laura Kamoie wrote the desperately sad section at the end that made me cry so much, which is perhaps why she also struck me as the most empathetic of the authors. I had the chance to briefly speak with her twice, to my delight. I attribute this to my red scarf, so if you do attend an author event, consider dressing in-theme—I’m guessing my scarf caught their eye!
ALL of the authors were so articulate, passionate, and informed. Eliza Knight discussed her section on the infamous Charlotte Cordray, which was perhaps the most fascinating for its shock value.
Heather Webb may have had the most challenging job—to make us empathetic towards one of the most radical, less-educated characters.
Anyhow, there was something quite exciting about all the authors being there as a group, so many fabulous scribblers at once!
I bought a paper copy of Ribbons of Scarlet, even though I already had it on Kindle AND audiobook. Sigh! I did it just for their autographs. The duplicate expense (not so much of an expense…) and the four hours of driving (more of an issue…) were totally worth it for me, though I went home thinking how exhausting it must be for them, having to talk in front of everyone and then go and lecture again later that day—plus packing their luggage and checking in new places and all. I’m happy they came fairly near me, though, and I hope they are still having fun with their tour! What amazing company they must be for each other!
Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web.
Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app.
Loading your book clubs
There was a problem loading your book clubs. Please try again.
Not in a club? Learn more
Join or create book clubs
Choose books together
Track your books
Bring your club to Amazon Book Clubs, start a new book club and invite your friends to join, or find a club that’s right for you for free.
Something went wrong. Please try your request again later.
Add a debit or credit card to save time when you check out
Convenient and secure with 2 clicks. Add your card
Customers who bought this item also bought
Page 1 of 1 Start overPage 1 of 1
Popular Highlights in this book
Sympathy is our most natural and moral sense. And its origin is pain.Highlighted by 84 Kindle readers- This “best of times . . . worst of times” era marks one of the earliest appearances in the Western world of women demanding expanded rights—including the right to vote.Highlighted by 78 Kindle readers
- They killed us for being too political, too intelligent, too opinionated, too daring, too pretty.Highlighted by 65 Kindle readers
Reviews with images
Liberty! Equality! Sorority! — Hope!
Just finished this fantastic book. So good, couldn’t put it down. Kudos to each & all, & to @WmMorrowBooks for giving it the attention it deserves. Great job of highlighting relevance to now. Loved learning about these heroines. #ribbonsofscarlet 🙌🏻 #ReadThis #HistFic #womenI’ve read a great deal about the French Revolution, including many of the books suggested, of course including Hilary Mantel’s A Place if Greater Safety. It’s a different world than it was when Mantel wrote that book, and I quite enjoyed the tables being turned. It also reminded me (from the comfort of the distant past) of how women have been treated, are being treated in this country. And the lovely thing about that is, this book stokes the flames of hope and strength, of speaking out about the wrongs regardless of risk, of the knowledge of the last, which reminds me of why I think the present is so dangerous. I’ve never thought about just how many acts of women turned the tides of the revolution and the terror, but this book laid it all out perfectly for me.
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
Reviewed in the United States on November 18, 2019
Reviewed in the United States on October 14, 2019
Reviewed in the United States on October 7, 2019
Reviewed in the United States on November 16, 2019
Top reviews from other countries
Shorty Sherry
Written by 6 women based on the women of the Revolution
Reviewed in Canada on May 31, 2022
Emilia Mori
La Rivoluzione francese dal punto di vista delle donne
Reviewed in Italy on March 6, 2020
