"He showed me an island smeared in blood, and I fell in love with it."I received an ARC from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. My thoughts and opinions are my own. Any quotes I use are from an unpublished copy and may not reflect the finished product.Songs from the Deep had me mesmerized from the start! One look at the cover, and then𑁋BAM!𑁋I was hooked. It's both elegant and haunting, and subtly captures the heart of the story. Moira has always felt a connection with the sirens, although she doesn't understand exactly what it is that captivates and draws her to them. Her father's work, maybe. She knows they are predators despite her fascination, and acknowledges that when they kill it isn't malicious. They're just doing what comes naturally to them. Her descriptions of their deadly beauty only increased my curiosity as the story progressed. I particularly enjoyed her stolen moments in the cliff crevices to observe them unseen.Despite the book being about sirens, they don't play a prominent role in the story. They're mostly in the background, and there's very little interaction between them and our main character. At first I was disappointed because I really wanted to see the story from the siren's perspective, but after awhile I started to appreciate the mystery surrounding their existence. No one knows where they come from, or why they made this particular island their home. Do they exist elsewhere? What do they do beneath the water? How do they communicate? I thought it was a very unique way to tell the story, and thought their silent presence spoke volumes.The atmospheric setting was incredibly well-written. I could see the moors, the heather bending to the whims of the wind, and an island that was beautifully dangerous. The islanders know the tricks and safety measures to keep the sirens away, but death has still found it's way into the hearts and homes of most of the island's residents.The mystery was an integral part of the story, since that's what Moira and Jude are focused on throughout the book, but it was the little things that really kept my interest. Moira playing the violin, Jude tending to the lighthouse, the sirens lounging in the sand. The mystery wasn't very mysterious, and didn't take a lot of guesswork to solve. Jude's locked room and hidden noises were somewhat obvious, and the suspects weren't too difficult to suss out. I wish the twists and reveals had been a little more unexpected and unpredictable, but it didn't detract from my enjoyment.I wasn't sure what to expect when I started this book, but I assumed there would be a lot of input from the sirens themselves. I was pleasantly surprised to learn otherwise, and thought the author did a remarkable job of creating a haunting tale that circumvented what little expectations I had. They mystery itself wasn't surprising, but the story's ability to feel like it's own character -- amazing. I also really liked the dialogue, and how characters would "doff" their hats. Everything was proper and respectable, even with an unsolved murder and siren attacks."Perhaps it explains why the sea takes secrets for a wish. They are the truest part of us."Originally posted at Do You Dog-ear? on November 7, 2019.